CLEMSON — Here is Clemson’s dilemma.
Next year, Graham Neff is expected to entrust around $40 million to the football program.
He is entrusting that person or persons to spend the $40 million in a way that will best benefit Clemson in constructing its 2027 football roster. In other words, will that person do what is in the best interest of Clemson to get the Tigers back at the top of the ACC and competing for College Football Playoff berths, as well as national championships?
Is Dabo Swinney the guy to entrust that money with? Is Swinney the guy to get Clemson back to the top of the mountain?
Or?
Does Swinney need help? Does Clemson Athletics bring someone in just to help football—a general manager—and help select players that will put a competitive roster in place.
We know how Swinney feels about it. He let it be known what he wants and what he is not going to do.
“I am going to make the roster decisions as the head coach. I don’t make them all by myself. Collectively, that is what we do. But we are not going to hire somebody to come in and say, ‘Hey, this is your roster.’”
But what if this is what Clemson wants? What if Clemson wants to bring someone in to help build a roster and work alongside Swinney to get the job done?
What if this person worked under the athletic director and reported to the athletic director instead of Swinney?
This is the $40 million question. That is why I asked who would you trust.
Personally, I am going with the general manager.
Why?
What has Swinney done in the last five years since the NIL and transfer portal era began to make me think he can build a competitive roster that is in the best interest of the Clemson football program? (i.e. this year’s QB and OL issues).
If you have not noticed, since 2021, Clemson has slipped from being one of the nation’s elite programs to a great program to a good program to, now, what is considered an average program.
Yes, Dabo Swinney has done a lot of great things for the Clemson football program. He is the winningest coach not only at Clemson, but in the ACC too. He has won two national titles and nine ACC Championships. He one day will be in the College Football Hall of Fame.
No one is trying to take those accomplishments away. Swinney will always be considered the greatest coach Clemson has ever had.
However, what Swinney accomplished has long ended. It’s been six years since the glory days, if you will. Those days of undefeated and one loss regular seasons have come and gone.
In this new world of College Football, Clemson has not competed very well.
I know some of you are thinking, “Will, if he doesn’t agree to use a GM what do we do? We can’t let him go because we will have to pay him a $57 million buyout.”
But that is where you are mistaken. Clemson can pay the $57 million, as I document in a column a few weeks back.
It is simple. If Clemson provides the resources to be successful and it expresses it wants a true football general manager in place to help make better roster decisions than Swinney has the last few years, and Swinney becomes stubborn and refuses to work with the general manager.
Then I think you know what Clemson and athletic director Graham Neff have to do.
We have all seen Swinney’s way in this new world of college football, and we all know it is not working. It’s time to put someone else in charge of roster management.
That is who I will entrust the $40 million with.