Thursday Insider: Change is in the Wind at Clemson

Change is in the wind at Clemson.

We won’t go into too much detail, but we can tell you that things are progressing down a path that will bring significant changes to Clemson football.

Roster Spend Not a Lifetime Achievement Award

For the second week in a row Swinney spent part of his Tuesday press conference appearing to negotiate in public. As we’ve already reported conversations about need changes have gone on for a while. And they now continue to be made in public.

The financials are dictating the need for change.

Nobody is arguing the historic things Swinney has done with the Clemson football program. Every Clemson fan will always be thankful to Swinney for the amazing years.

However, times have changed and now boosters, fans and businesses are being asked to contribute a very significant amount each year to pay players for that year’s roster. Coaches salaries are tied to lifetime achievement, facility raises provide benefits for many years, but the annual roster need is for a single season.

For the 2026 roster, Clemson had to raise around 30 million just to pay for the roster. That is just for the roster. That does not include the money to pay coaches, facilities and other needs for the program.

The ROI for this year’s roster spend was horrible as was the ROI for 2025’s roster spend. Next year’s roster is expected to cost around 40 million.

You can’t keep going back to that well and ask them to give what is needed when the right decisions are not being made to put the best product on the field for that year’s roster and provide the best ROI. Swinney’s decisions have been well documented.

It is Not Just a Two-Year Slide

Swinney focused in his press conference on the last two seasons. This has not been just a two year slide. If the Tigers lose to Duke Friday night this will be the third time in four years that they have gone 4-4 in the ACC. Not the SEC or Big Ten, but the ACC. The 2023, 2025, 2026 seasons would all end with a 4-4 league record.

Three out of the last four years the Tigers would be 4-4 in the ACC, which has not happened since the 2002-’05 campaigns. The last time the Tigers were 4-4 in the league in consecutive years came in 2004 and 2005.

The last time Duke beat Clemson three times in a row was from 1934-1957 when it won four in a row in the series, including three consecutive years from 1934-36.

While Clemson was refusing to use the portal to make the roster better, recruiting was also slipping. In 2020, the Tigers had the No. 3 class nationally in the composite team rankings. In 2021, it was No. 5. In 2022, it was No. 10. In 2023 and 2024, it was No. 11. In 2025, it fell to No. 26, and last year’s class was No. 20.

Another way to look at things is that as the football roster spending increased dramatically the last few years, the recruiting went down significantly. In 2024, the roster spending was around $8 million. In 2025, it jumped to around $22 million and this year it jumped to 30 million.

While most teams were using a combination of the transfer portal and the recruiting class to build their “best” roster, Clemson was fighting with one hand tied behind their back.

TCI has talked with coaches at other schools a good bit over the past few years. Most have increased the reliance on the transfer portal after realizing it was easier to get players ready to make an impact immediately and also easier to identify how players will impact the program. When the philosophy is only to use the portal when you “have a spot to fill” you clearly are not putting the best roster on the field for a given season.

Yet you are asking your donors, fans and businesses to pay now $30 million and now $40 million for that roster. Nobody would run their business that way and yes college football is absolutely a business.

It Didn’t Have to Be This Way

The wounds are self-inflicted. Clemson’s rosters the past five years would have been without a doubt been better if Swinney had used the portal to make sure the Tigers put the best roster on the field. Instead, he had to be pulled kicking and screaming to use the portal more each year and his refusal to use the portal at quarterback and offensive line last offseason has the Tigers likely heading to another 4-4 season in the ACC.

We can tell you that from the first day of NIL and the transfer portal there were coaches and others within the football program at Clemson that wanted to do things differently. They knew the Tigers needed to embrace NIL and use the transfer portal to have the best chance to succeed on the field. Swinney drove the bus and we are where we are.

Central Office Not The Fix

We wanted to clear up some misconceptions about some changes in the athletic department. Clemson is making changes to a “Central Front Office” in the athletic department. These changes are certainly needed, but they are not a fix to the football roster management issues the Tigers have had.

Swinney addressed the centralized front office in his Tuesday press conference.

“The centralized front office is to handle all the front office stuff, and that needs to be put in place. It is a lot of money,” the head coach said. “And I have never dealt with that stuff.”

The Good News

If you are looking for hope for change, the good news is if Clemson uses the portal and the funding, they will have available correctly, it can be a quick turnaround. The examples are numerous around the country including Indiana, UCLA, Kentucky and others.

Spend doesn’t guarantee success as we’ve seen this season at Texas, LSU, Ole Miss and elsewhere. There is a path for quick change, however. The $40 million dollar is who will be making those decisions and will Clemson finally join the party.